Are Social Media Eclipsing Business Blogging

by Barry Welford July 13th, 2010 

The Wrong Question

In some ways I believe the question in the title is almost wholly wrong, but it seems to be a major topic of interest  if you do a search, as I did, for articles on business blogging.  If you feel it is inappropriate now, it was even more inappropriate in 2008.  However apparently Business Week did not think so.

In 2005, it published an article entitled Blogs will change your business.

Look past the yakkers, hobbyists, and political mobs. Your customers and rivals are figuring blogs out. Our advice: Catch up…or catch you later.

It was an excellent article and received wide coverage and many downloads.  So not surprisingly they updated it and reprinted it in 2008.  The surprise was that they changed the title.  Now they proclaimed, Social Media Will Change Your Business.

Why It Might Appear Logical

Although businesses in general are not moving en masse either to blogging or to involvement in the social media, it is not surprising that commentators might think that social media represented a more fruitful terrain to explore.

One indicator of this can be seen by using the Google Insights tool.  If you do a search for 'blog' then you see the results below:

blog interest

Over the years there has been a steady and gradual growth in searches for blog which is perhaps an indicator of the ongoing interest in blogs.

On the other hand if you do a search on Google Insights for Facebook, one of the social media, you get a dramatically different picture.  Facebook in the last three years has taken off almost exponentially.

facebook interest 

If you compare these two analyses in one picture, then you might feel the argument for getting involved in Facebook rather than blogging must be without question.  The line for blog can hardly be seen when measured against the scale required to display the Facebook explosion.

facebook vs blog interest

Why For Most Businesses,This Argument Is Wrong For Many Reasons

The fact that many, many more people are talking about Facebook than are talking about blogs does not necessarily prove that social media will be more useful to business than business blogs.  Indeed if you consider some of the factors involved, you may rapidly be dissuaded.

Social Media Are Often Trivial

swarm of bees

Unfortunately without question, a high proportion of the communication that takes place in social media is about very trivial matters.  Indeed a good article by Tom Davenport quantifies this as he laments, Let's Tweet About Something Important!

So here we are again: a promising new medium being used largely for vapid chattering about celebrities. Couldn't these technologies be used for good?

Unlike Social Media, Blogs Are Search Engine Friendly

Whereas social media have  immediate impact, they provide little visibility in search engine keyword searches.  This is where blogs have a real advantage since their natural architecture creates many links that are particularly important in Google searches.  Blogs also create associated RSS news feeds that provide instant impact in the news feed readers and increase the search engine visibility.

Business blogs provide information to searchers

Having a blog or blogs means that businesses can create for themselves privileged ways of communicating with searchers who are interested in their products and services.  Of course many of these searchers are also purchasers.  What could be better than coming on a prospect's radar screen as they are searching for possible suppliers.

bird with worm

Business Bloggers Make Mistakes

Given the above arguments, it might be assumed that a goodly proportion of businesses would have one or more business blogs.  This is far from the case.  What often seems to be the case is that a business starts off a blog with the very best of intentions but in some way loses the momentum.

A good article in Mashable, lists the Top 5 Business Blogging Mistakes and How to Avoid Them.  Here is their list of Mistakes:

  1. Treating Your Blog Like a Press Center
  2. Not Blogging Regularly
  3. Not Enabling Conversation
  4. Making New Content Hard to Discover
  5. Expecting Too Much, Too Soon

The blog will only be of interest to prospects and clients if these mistakes are avoided.  It is also usually true that whatever is proving weak for human readers may also represent weaknesses in gaining search engine visibility.

Social Media Are Not An Easier Solution

Lest it be thought that blogs represent the tough alternative, a major word of caution is appropriate about social media.  The very nature of social media is that people talk to people.  They do not wish to be talked at by companies seeking to hawk their wares.  It is therefore a tough challenge for any company to decide on the best way of letting their people be involved in social media activities.  As yet, there is not a large body of successful case studies to suggest the best approach.

Marketing Is a Dialogue

The best marketing communication is a dialogue between a business and its customers and prospects.  This can be difficult to manage in social media.  On the other hand, blogging is an ideal vehicle for such a dialogue.

The final choice in whether blogging or social media or both is the best strategy depends very much on the particular market.  If new products and services can easily create a buzz so that people want to tell their friends then social media should undoubtedly be included in the marketing mix.  For more technical products and services, social media will be less useful.  However in both cases appropriate blogs will provide an important support for other marketing initiatives.

Barry Welford

Offering practical, effective ways of strengthening Internet marketing strategy and getting bottom-line success, particularly through local SEO.

BPWrap

You May Also Like

3 Responses to “Are Social Media Eclipsing Business Blogging”

  1. Karen Swim says:

    Barry, I agree with you that many are asking the wrong question. Blogging is another social media tool, so the true question is what objectives are you trying to achieve and what are the best tools to help you attain them. Business blogging provides an opportunity for in depth discussions around your expertise where other social media tools are better suited to networking and customer service.
    .-= Karen Swim recently posted: Why Professionals Hate You =-.

  2. I would add to this that it is not one or the other. One of the best ways to pull in traffic to a blog post is through social media (I came here from Twitter). And one of the most useful things to do on social media is to send people to a blog post.

  3. Alex says:

    I have seen many markters moving from blog to twitter and other social media.

    I still believe in blog and i prefer to use social network to promote blogs.
    .-= Alex recently posted: Vacation =-.