Google Hotpot: Rate Any Place #googlefail

by Ruud Hein November 16th, 2010 

Google has introduced Google Hotpot, a user/community-driven ratings & reviews sites for businesses, restaurants, malls, etc.

Google Hotpot

What is Google Hotpot?

Google Hotpot is a site where people can rate restaurants, malls, supermarkets, coffeeshops, etc.

The idea is that by learning from what you enter and looking at what your friends like, Google Hotpot can give you recommendations for the best places to go to when you’re in another country, city, town, or neighborhood.

How Google Hotpot Works

When you arrive the first time you are welcomed and invited to set the (nick)name under which you want your reviews to be published.

image

Once filled in you get to the main screen where search is the primary mechanism to get to a place.

image

I entered the name of a buffet-style restaurant I happen to like. The system was smart enough to know where I am and didn’t suggests similar places elsewhere on the planet.

image

 

When you hover over the stars for the rating a little pop-up shows you what each star means:

image

Possible ratings are:

  • Hated It
  • Disliked It
  • It was okay
  • Liked it
  • Loved it

There is also a special super-rating available of which you only have 10 to begin with:

image

Once you rate the place the box flips around and prompts you for a review. You can either fill it in or leave it as is.

image

Once you start to write your review  additional rating metrics appear below the box.

image

Published ratings and reviews appear in the regular Google search results whether users are signed in or not.

image 

Publicly the ratings and review are then available on the Google Places page for that business.

image

The Problem With Google Hotpotimage

Hotpot tastes better with friends”, says Google – and that’s precisely the problem: my friends  — and yours – aren’t “on” Google.

The only “friends” I have who and have a Google user account and are officially signed in and would use this service are colleagues within the search & marketing industries and a handful of technology thought leaders.

I don’t know any “normal” people who will flock to this service.

  • The value comes from community feedback but there is no community
    Yelp has community. Tons of it. Google Hotpot has none. All Google’s social projects suffer from the very thing that makes Google the #1 search engine: the cost of switching is zero and therefore people won’t switch.

    "Zero switching costs lead to a winner-take-all market for the leader. Even a modest initial lead will snowball until majority market share is reached and maintained. This is because, faced with a choice between two products, in the absence of switching costs users will choose the better one, even if it is only slightly better."
    Winner-Take-All: Google and the Third Age of Computing

  • Add friends – again?!
    There is an add fatigue in online social services. I understand Google doesn’t want to auto-add people the way they blundered with Google Buzz but seriously … no, I don’t want to do this again. Especially because the payback is zero.
  • Web 1.5 social model
    Anno Facebook/Twitter the very thought that I would travel to another place and would need a setup like Google Hotpot or even Yelp to figure out what’s good is dated.
    In an age where you can extract Likes from the social graph, asking me to enter it specifically doesn’t work.

What This Means For You

Google Hotpot might make adding ratings and reviews a bit more inviting to some people. The vast majority of web users will post there comments on Facebook and Twitter though.

That said, ratings via Google appear at several keypoints – like the search results page – so you will want to have some reviews, some ratings, and certainly monitor what goes on here so you can react and respond to reviews, if needed.

Ruud Hein

My paid passion at Search Engine People sees me applying my passions and knowledge to a wide array of problems, ones I usually experience as challenges. People who know me know I love coffee.

Ruud Hein

You May Also Like

15 Responses to “Google Hotpot: Rate Any Place #googlefail”

  1. Thank you for keeping your finger on the pulse and summarizing the latest Google fail. Looks like another copycat amalgamation in an attempt at social media.

  2. Kyle Alm says:

    You would have thought that they would have learned their lesson from Wave. They had tons of hype and interest and no community. At least Google Places have a built-in audience, but this whole idea tastes like fail.

    Google really doesn't get social and I don't think users are really comfortable with Google having that much information.

  3. Terry Van Horne says:

    Yikes…. tough audience. I like this I think this is a small part of bigger puzzle. Google Local was absurdly easy to game… so much so real marketers left it to the cowboys. I'm thinking that changes with this, the recent change to the Local Universals and the Product Feeds announcement are Game changers. I know I am looking at putting a client into these programs because in some form or another they will be around for a while.

  4. Interesting take Ruud. Terry … The problem is that EVERYTHING is easy to game and some do it rampantly whether it's on Twitter, (the old) Digg, etc. When it comes to user generated reviews, it's probably gamed more than anything else. Google's partners were gamed already. This move actually could help? Whether it's cars, hotels, airlines, they all have people posting their own stuff. More importantly, real users are MUCH more likely to post negative reviews than positive ones. Tripadvisor has made numerous public attempts to clean this up.
    .-= Charlie Anzman recently posted: Google Launches hotpot – Your Reviews in Places and More =-.

  5. Alex says:

    Hotpot definitely missed the mark on this first release, but they still have a chance:
    http://blog.alexbovee.com/post/1604075768/three-ideas-for-improving-googles-hotpot
    .-= Alex recently posted: Three Ideas for Improving Googles Hotpot =-.

  6. [...] Ruud Hein at SearchEnginePeople.com calls hotpot Google’s latest attempt to create community feedback where there is no community. [...]

  7. [...] Ruud Hein at SearchEnginePeople.com calls hotpot Google’s latest attempt to create community feedback where there is no community. [...]

  8. [...] Ruud Hein at SearchEnginePeople.com calls hotpot Google’s latest attempt to create community feedback where there is no community. [...]

  9. [...] Ruud Hein at SearchEnginePeople.com calls hotpot Google’s latest attempt to create community feedback where there is no community. [...]

  10. [...] Ruud Hein at SearchEnginePeople.com calls hotpot Google’s latest attempt to create community feedback where there is no community. [...]

  11. [...] Ruud Hein at SearchEnginePeople.com calls hotpot Google’s latest attempt to create community feedback where there is no community. [...]

  12. [...] Ruud Hein at SearchEnginePeople.com calls hotpot Google’s latest attempt to create community feedback where there is no community. [...]