Social Media Optimization Assets : The Fake User
Snatch of conversation:
- I beg your pardon? Assets? You probably meant to say “puppets” didn’t you?
- Whatever you call them, dear: puppets, fake accounts or users, bots, tools… assets!
- Hm… But the creation of err… sock err … fake err …multiple accounts within one community most often goes against their T&C…
- Yes, of course it does, but it can’t effectively be policed and it can’t possibly be ever enforced…
As you rightly guessed, today’s subject for our discussion is one of the most controversial SMO assets – artificial user. The activity that’s clearly out of the bounds and borders of white-hat SMO but nevertheless is so mildly greyish that for many it’s too hard to resist the temptation. Even if you don’t have any immediate plans to jump straight into it, I’m sure that you are at least curious to see what other are doing in the meantime.
The ultimate aim, the final goal of user development is the creation of user model capable most effectively (in the shortest period and at the lowest possible cost for the owner) to carry out specific functions. The creation of powerful or influential user shouldn’t be the end goal by itself, but it’s always aimed at achieving some other result.
The real problem as soon as you enter this rather grey area comes from the fact that it’s much too easy to confuse means and ends and become carried away by the flow forgetting why you started this project in the first place. There needs to be some kind of structural approach, some methodology, so to speak and I’m willing to share some basic tips and tricks I’ve learned myself while observing multiple SMO campaigns. This list is by no means complete of even approaching this stage. Think of it as a teaser, a starting point to provoke a discussion on the subject.
Before you engage for whatever reasons in this shady activity, you better go through this short checklist that might save you from falling into some traps already well explored by many well before you.
Ready To Be A Fake User?
First and foremost think why you might need to create a swarm of fake user accounts? How will it help? I understand the attractiveness of the idea, and especially to those who already displaying some symptoms of schizophrenia, but will this really help? Creating and managing puppet user accounts is like playing a SimCity and I observe quite many ordinary users doing it just for the sheer joy of the process.
But we are different, aren’t we? We have our goals clearly defined and our targets set. So, again, think of your goals first! Will this method be the most effective and the most economic for you. Wouldn’t it be easier and cheaper just to buy a traditional advertising campaign or sell your stuff to influential bloggers that are already there in some other way? Consider all your pros and cons first but if after careful consideration you still decided to go ahead with it, it might be of some help going through this checklist I complied.
The Fake User Checklist
Any character development starts from defining the following:
- Function and Aim: in the most cases it will be
- Advertising/Negative Advertising: open or hidden popularization, propaganda, promotion and vice versa of product, service, ideas – whatever you want, really
Note: you have to decide from a start: does user have both functions or only one. Why? Because there are situations when if you are “for” something/someone you are automatically “against” the opposite thing. You can’t support both Obama and McCain with one character without running into some sort of internal contradiction. To be believable your character must be consistent! Consistency is the key to this whole business and hence you need to plan your consistent user in advance.
- User Type: No community no matter if it’s real or virtual may exist without certain types of members. Each village must have its village idiot just as well as its village head.
There two different approaches in defining the type:
- Easy way: pain-in-the-you-know-what, kiss-up, sexy blonde, moaner, mom, plain stupid, bitch, sweetie, techie geek and etc. Sounds familiar doesn’t it? Identify what type of character is missing or weak (almost dead and easily replaced) among the existing users within the targeted community (you must already have list of networks, services and cheat sheet on them where the user will take actions) and fit your character into that niche. Well, alternatively you might decide to create a double of a user type already existing in a given community, but beware the conflict between the two is just around the corner, so this might be useful only if you feel strong enough to energize the community with almost unstoppable stream of flame. Note: remember that chosen user type should fit easy and nicely (please, do not place stupid blondie into techie-geeks-programmers-hackers-and-admins comminity)
- Not so easy: creation of absolutely unknown user type – unique combination of characteristics wich produces a new type.
- Personality: full freedom for your imagination.
Note: all personality characteristics and parameters must correlate with user type.
- Characteristics and Parameters: name/nickname, date of birth, location, avatar, list of interests/likes/dislikes, bio, vocabulary.
Note: empty profile always works against you. Why? There’s nothing more annoying in the Internet than an empty profile. Empty profile is the first giveaway for a puppet user and we don’t need to expose it right away.
- Actions or the combination of actions:
- Networking:
- Where? – List of a combination of networks/services/communities ideally correlated with user type and personality.
- With Whom? Who is going to be your friends or opponents? It may vary from influential power users to ordinary users or you can take a combined approach.
- How? – Friending, following, staking and migration of existed friends, followers, stalkers into other online communities.
- Blogging: Surprisingly the least important part of character development – who reads blog posts these days?
Define:
- blogging subjects, the combination of subjects: art, politics, IT and etc (must correlate with user profile interests and be internally consistent)
- frequency (timetable), volume (small, medium, big), quality of postings (notes, blah, articles and etc)
- Participation: Starting threads, commenting, voting, groups making, group’s participation.
Think carefully what kind of participation is for your user as some might hardly be justified in terms of time and resources needed. You don’t need to waste your time moderating a group about knitting in some remote community while your target audience are devoted fishermen.
Hard Work = ROI
As you can see the creation of artificial user is quite labor-intensive process, needless to say quite difficult to manage as well.
But there is an important thought you should always remember; after you succeed with building a “tool” it will become a unique Social Media Optimization asset, which has its own value and price – sometimes higher than media campaign for which it was created.
Lora Lufark aka SexySEO, self-described geeky Internet avant-gardist, does SEO and Social Media Optimizaton
Images courtesy of K W Reinsch, Vitor Guerson and mistersnappy
Leave a Reply
Get the SEP Newsletter
I look at the alias, sock puppet, alter ego debate like this.
Being involved in this business means doing research into a lot of areas, which in turn makes us all a touch closer to the multiple personality disorder diagnosis.
So using a number of personalities and molding them for a specific niche is a handy thing.
Not that this is bad. It allows a deeper understanding of a variety of business models to be able to handle a wider and more diverse client base.
This is a good thing from where I sit.
I consider the use of the alter ego, when used with a modicum of respect to be a very useful tool.
Writers have been using effectively for centuries.
I must confess though I hadn't broken it down to this extent before. Thanks for taking it to the next level for me.
Hmmm… Should we really be promoting this type of behaviour? Looks like another hit to our collective reputation as online marketers. Is it any wonder most social media users hate us?
I've done this before in the past with great results. I'm not talking about just spamming out comments/friend requests. I've built a few very nice looking profiles and had a lot of natural traffic and communications come through the profile. There is a point of taking it too far, but a few profiles here and there never hurt anyone…
This is an oldie, but goodie. It does take some work, but the benefits are definitely there.
Considering the ethics…it's a gray area. It all depends on how far you push it.
Yes I agree with you – creation of artificial user is quite labor-intensive process, and maintaining them is a headeck, besides sooner or later the anti spam means of that particular system will catch you.
I've seen cases where fake users actually trashed a company's image. While conversing with yourself can be productive, there are destructive methods to this technique as well.
This is a lot of work, and if the ROI is good it can be worthwhile.