Google Being Backed Into A Corner?

by Donna Fontenot December 13th, 2007 

John Battelle has listed an exhaustive list of questions that a House Representative is asking Google to answer. This representative is "the senior Republican on the House Energy and Commerce Committee, which has Internet regulation as one of its responsibilities." I won't list all of the questions (see Mr. Battelle's post for that), but here's an example (after asking a bunch of privacy-related questions about the data Google obtains:

2. Please explain how Google uses the information or data described in Question 1(a) - (l), including, but not limited to, the following uses: perfecting Google's search algorithm; operating Google's advertising programs such as AdWords and AdSense; and research or analysis of user activity on

Mr. Battelle says he is eager to see what response Google will give. I believe that response will be something along the lines of "We're sorry, but we cannot divulge that information because it would be tantamount to giving away our secret sauce". I don't know how much legal authority a House representative has to force Google to answer any of these questions. I'm not well-versed in politics or legal matters. But I'd be willing to bet that Google will do everything in its power to NOT answer most or all of those questions. I'd also be willing to bet that they will prevail and will NOT have to answer them.

What do you think? Can they be forced to answer them? Will they answer them of their own volition? Should they?

UPDATE ON 12/22 - Google answered with a 19-page pdf! Read it for yourself. :)

You May Also Like

4 Responses to “Google Being Backed Into A Corner?”

  1. DK says:

    Google is going to skirt the entire event, as they dont feel they have to answer to anyone.. Just think if Gov pissed G off one day, they could remove all the GOV/IRS sites for 60 days to show them who is boss. LOL

  2. g1smd says:

    Looks like they want to know how the whole thing works. The answer to that must be a resounding "not telling". Are they asking the same question of Yahoo, Live and Ask?

    I assume they would refer them to the various Google patents.

  3. Tom says:

    I agree with DK. Congress may just end up losing this near trillion dollar company to Mexico! Then Matt would have to change his name to Manuel Cutts.